Click image to open full size
How Public Goods Differ From Private Goods
Non-rival, non-excludable, and the free rider problem
Related Worksheets
Economics sorts goods by how people use them and whether people can be kept from using them. Public goods are shared by many people at the same time, while private goods are usually owned and used by one buyer at a time. This difference matters because it helps explain why some things are sold in stores and others are provided by governments or communities. Examples like streetlights, clean air, and national defense show why markets do not always provide enough of every good on their own.
The two key ideas are rivalry and excludability. A good is rival if one person's use leaves less for someone else, and it is excludable if people can be prevented from using it unless they pay. Public goods are usually non-rival and non-excludable, which can create a free rider problem when people benefit without paying directly. Because of this, governments often provide public goods and pay for them with taxes so that the whole community can benefit.
Key Facts
- Private goods are rival and excludable, such as pizza, shoes, and movie tickets.
- Public goods are non-rival and non-excludable, such as national defense and many streetlights.
- Non-rival means one person's use does not significantly reduce another person's use.
- Non-excludable means it is difficult or impossible to stop non-payers from benefiting.
- Free rider problem: people may use a public good without paying for it, so markets may provide too little of it.
- Total cost per person can be estimated as cost per person = total cost ÷ number of people.
Vocabulary
- Public good
- A good that is non-rival and non-excludable, so many people can benefit from it at the same time and non-payers are hard to exclude.
- Private good
- A good that is rival and excludable, meaning one person's use reduces what is left for others and sellers can require payment.
- Non-rival
- A good is non-rival when one person using it does not significantly reduce the amount available for others.
- Non-excludable
- A good is non-excludable when it is difficult to prevent people from using or benefiting from it.
- Free rider
- A free rider is someone who benefits from a good or service without paying directly for it.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Calling anything owned by the government a public good is wrong because public goods are defined by non-rivalry and non-excludability, not by who owns them.
- Thinking public goods are always free is wrong because they still have costs, often paid through taxes or community funding.
- Confusing public parks with perfect public goods is wrong because parks can become crowded and access can sometimes be limited.
- Assuming markets always provide enough public goods is wrong because the free rider problem can make businesses unwilling to supply them at the socially useful level.
Practice Questions
- 1 A town installs streetlights that cost $24,000 per year. If 3,000 residents share the cost equally through taxes, what is the cost per resident per year?
- 2 A pizza has 8 slices and 4 friends each eat 2 slices. Is the pizza rival or non-rival, and why?
- 3 Classify national defense as a public good or private good. Explain your answer using the ideas of rivalry and excludability.